Scoutmaster Musings - Letter or Spirit?

> > > Triple Prizes < < < 

Scoutmaster Musings

Letter or Spirit?
Eagle Scout Suspended for having a tiny pocketknife in his car parked on school property.

Cub Scout Suspended for eating lunch with his pocketknife-fork-spoon.

Zero-tolerance policies are all the rage. The problem with "zero" is that there is no leeway and no way to use the brain God gave you with which to think. Policies set up with absolutes often cause a mess.

These two scouts didn't follow the rules and they both understand that. But, one minute of talking to the 'offenders' and any sane person could tell there was no danger to others posed here - anyway, no more than from the pencils, pens, backpack straps, belt chains, hair picks, rulers, compasses, protractors, ... and the infinite other potential weapons that exist at school and in everyday life.

The spirit of safety policies are, of course, to keep people safe. When those in authority drift from the spirit to the letter of the written policy, they tarnish their reputation and lose respect.

It happens in scouting too. Scouts are good at figuring out ways around troop policies and game rules. We just had a good discussion about electronics use at troop activities. It ranged from "zero-tolerance" to "whatever". Once the discussion clarified what our goals in limiting electronics were, it became much easier to define how scouts are expected to act with these tools rather than banning them.

We're fortunate. In the Scout Law and Oath, we have pretty much all the behavioral expectations set for everyone to understand and accept. Not much more is really needed besides that.

Scout On

Posted: 16:22 10-13-2009 451
    Previous Post     Next Post        archives:   2015  2014  2013  2012  2011  2010  2009  2008  2007  2006  2005      Scoutmaster Musings - RSS Feed

Site Disclosure Statement

 Nov 11, 2009 - Mark Fisher
Iam fairly new to Scouting - i year as a Wolf dad and currently a Bear dad - so I'm still learning too.
The biggest issue I have with the cubscout bringing his utility knife to school has more to do with his parents. I have no doubt the youngster had no ill will or intentions, yet as parents we should be on top of this. Back in my years of scholl, any punk or bully would only be glad to steal your pocket knife. I myself would have proudly showed off my scout utility knife had I had one. Unfortuneatly, we know that proudly showing off can very easily turn into: "WHOOPS! somebody got accidentally cut!"
I feel the parenst should have instilled a sense of be proud of what you have done/ what you have earned, what you own, but also be aware .
Again, I'm still new at this, and may be totally over reating.
As far as the scholls handeling of it...well, this is the same entity that expells for mouthwash, yet can't can't afford teachers for all the million dollar football stadiums and full complimet of coaching staff.

Follow Me, Boys

Recent Comments
Sebastian on /content/skit/i_gotta_go_wee-98.asp
Scouter Paul on Arrow of Light
Thomas on Map Test
RON TUFANKJIAN on Shotgun m.b.
David Marcus on Rain song
Anne Marie on Belt Loops
Ella on Arrow of Light
Shawn O'Brien on Tree Climber skit
Jason Manstream on Geocaching MB
Major Dad on Msgr Peace Award
More Comments...

Contest   -   Ask a Question   -   Add Content   -   scout software

This site is not officially associated with the Boy Scouts of America
listeria testingscout software
Boy Scouts  
Boy Scout Trail
Cub Scouts
Boy Scouts
My Blog

Group Games
Merit Badges
SM Minutes
Pen Pals

Online Tests
Our Schedule
Our Progress


Shop 4 Stuff
Privacy Policy
ICRA labeled

Find more Scouting Resources at
This site is not officially associated with the Boy Scouts of America
Boy Scout Trail Home Bobcat Tiger Cub Scout Wolf Cub Scout Bear Cub Scout Webelos Boy Scout Tenderfoot Scout 2nd Class Scout 1st Class Scout Star Scout Life Scout Eagle Scout