Scoutmaster Musings - The Taming


> > > Triple Prizes < < < 

Scoutmaster Musings

The Taming
I've spent quite a few hours over the past year reading some Baden-Powell writings and some early year Scoutmaster handbooks. As I read them, I can see my friends and me doing exactly what they describe - running through fields for no reason but to run, doing things our own way whether right or wrong, turning anything at all into a game. As I've reflected on these books and tried to use what I can from them to improve what our troop offers for the scouts, I've run into a tough realization over and over.

I can't help but notice that boys have been tamed. Given complete leeway to choose absolutely any activity for a troop meeting, we still sit in rows of chairs, have announcements, have instruction, and sit. We have no one tussling, rough-housing, even thumb wrestling. Nothing gets broken, no clothes get ripped. These scouts appear to prefer to sit and listen to someone talk than go outside and climb a tree. Even with direct prompting from me at the PLC meetings, an active game just isn't part of a meeting. I must be wrong. There must be something I'm missing.

When we're on campouts, if there is any free time, they sit. They don't run off and explore or get in trouble. They just sit and maybe work on some advancement.

It's almost like watching tamed bears. They do neat tricks, but you just know they should naturally be doing something else. It may be that our community, in general, is very driven to have kids excel. Since kindergarten, organized activities such as school, sports, music, and playgroups have dominated these boys' lives. Maybe they really don't know how to cut loose and have fun without a schedule and a goal. But, it's probably just that they are used to troop meetings being a certain way and they're in a rut.

So, now I'm at the 'lets try an experiment' point. And, that's what I'm planning for the next few months. I'm collecting a bunch of things my buddies and I used to do. Stuff like pitching pennies, pen guns, match rockets, hand slaps, tree climbing, rock skipping, whatever I can remember. At the next PLC, I'll ask the SPL if I could have a 10-15 minute chunk of time at the next 4 troop meetings for a Scoutmaster Challenge or some such thing.

Assuming the SPL agrees, then I'll get an Assistant Scoutmaster for each patrol and explain the plan to them. At the meeting, they'll each take a patrol and show them the activity and then step back and let the scouts play. I don't think we'll have competitions, but if the scouts move towards that, then great!

After a few meetings I'll know if this has become a part of the meeting that scouts look forward to or not. If it is, then I'll need to chat with the PLC about the experiment and how it's time for me to step back and they can start an SPL Challenge instead. Hopefully, that will be a good start to some brainstorming of active games to try. If that happens, it will be a good big step back towards FUN.

Scout On
Posted: 16:11 11-02-2007 248
    Previous Post     Next Post        archives:   2013  2012  2011  2010  2009  2008  2007  2006  2005      Scoutmaster Musings - RSS Feed

Site Disclosure Statement



Follow Me, Boys


Recent Comments
joseph on Boy Scout Uniform
 
Dawn on Webelos Super NOVA award
 
Anna R. on Arrow of Light
 
Steve Bechtel on Cub Knife post
 
Tyquesha Wilcox on /content/game/trash_ball-1583.asp
 
Jack on Map Test
 
Lena on Webelos Uniform
 
Wally Curran on Rank Advancements
 
Larry V on Golf MB
 
Jodi H on Outdoor Activity award
 
More Comments...


Contest   -   Ask a Question   -   Add Content   -   scout software

This site is not officially associated with the Boy Scouts of America
listeria testingscout softwareAmerican Business merit badge American Cultures merit badge American Heritage merit badge American Labor merit badge Animal Science merit badge Archaeology merit badge Archery merit badge Architecture merit badge Art merit badge Astronomy merit badge Athletics merit badge Atomic Energy merit badge Automotive Maintenance merit badge Aviation merit badge Backpacking merit badge Basketry merit badge Bird Study merit badge Bugling merit badge Camping merit badge Canoeing merit badge Carpentry merit badge Chemistry merit badge Chess merit badge Cinematography merit badge Citizenship in the Community merit badge Citizenship in the Nation merit badge Citizenship in the World merit badge Climbing merit badge Coin Collecting merit badge Collections merit badge Communications merit badge Composite Materials merit badge Computers merit badge Cooking merit badge Crime Prevention merit badge Cycling merit badge Dentistry merit badge Disabilities Awareness merit badge Dog Care merit badge Drafting merit badge Electricity merit badge Electronics merit badge Emergency Preparedness merit badge Energy merit badge Engineering merit badge Entrepreneurship merit badge Environmental Science merit badge Family Life merit badge Farm Mechanics merit badge Fingerprinting merit badge Fire Safety merit badge First Aid merit badge Fish and Wildlife Management merit badge Fishing merit badge Fly Fishing merit badge Forestry merit badge Gardening merit badge Genealogy merit badge Geocaching merit badge Geology merit badge Golf merit badge Graphic Arts merit badge Hiking merit badge Home Repairs merit badge Horsemanship merit badge Indian Lore merit badge Insect Study merit badge Inventing merit badge Journalism merit badge Kayaking merit badge Landscape Architecture merit badge Law merit badge Leatherwork merit badge Lifesaving merit badge Mammal Study merit badge Medicine merit badge Metalwork merit badge Model Design and Building merit badge Motorboating merit badge Music merit badge Nature merit badge Nuclear Science merit badge Oceanography merit badge Orienteering merit badge Painting merit badge Pathfinding merit badge Personal Fitness merit badge Personal Management merit badge Pets merit badge Photography merit badge Pioneering merit badge Plant Science merit badge Plumbing merit badge Pottery merit badge Public Health merit badge Public Speaking merit badge Pulp and Paper merit badge Radio merit badge Railroading merit badge Reading merit badge Reptile and Amphibian Study merit badge Rifle Shooting merit badge Robotics merit badge Rowing merit badge Safety merit badge Salesmanship merit badge Scholarship merit badge Scouting Heritage merit badge Scuba Diving merit badge Sculpture merit badge Search and Rescue merit badge Shotgun Shooting merit badge Signaling merit badge Skating merit badge Small-Boat Sailing merit badge Snow Sports merit badge Soil and Water Conservation merit badge Space Exploration merit badge Sports merit badge Stamp Collecting merit badge Surveying merit badge Swimming merit badge Textile merit badge Theater merit badge Tracking merit badge Traffic Safety merit badge Truck Transportation merit badge Veterinary Medicine merit badge Water Sports merit badge Weather merit badge Welding merit badge Whitewater merit badge Wilderness Survival merit badge Wood Carving merit badge Woodworking merit badge
Boy Scouts  
Boy Scout Trail
Cub Scouts
Webelos
Boy Scouts
My Blog

Activities
Advancements
Awards
Ceremonies
Group Games
Graces
Jokes
Merit Badges
Projects
Recipes
Skits
Songs
SM Minutes
Stories
Uniforms
Pen Pals

Library
Online Tests
Our Schedule
Our Progress


Supporters




Shop 4 Stuff
Visitors
Links
Privacy Policy
ICRA labeled

 
Find more Scouting Resources at www.BoyScoutTrail.com
This site is not officially associated with the Boy Scouts of America
Boy Scout Trail Home Bobcat Tiger Cub Scout Wolf Cub Scout Bear Cub Scout Webelos Boy Scout Tenderfoot Scout 2nd Class Scout 1st Class Scout Star Scout Life Scout Eagle Scout